When Fear Makes the Decision for You: The Hidden Cost of Doing Nothing
Thought For The Week
I’ve come to realise that many of the things in my life I’m most proud of have something in common with the things I most regret:
Fear.
The times when I left behind a life that was safe and familiar; when I chose uncertainty in pursuit of something that mattered deeply to me; when I started before I felt ready.
Those choices didn’t feel brave at the time. They felt scary.
But so did the difficult conversations I never had; the questions I didn’t ask; the opportunities I didn’t take.
The difference wasn’t the fear. It was what I did with it.
When fear persuades us not to act, the immediate result is usually relief. We don’t have to risk rejection, failure or embarrassment. We don’t have to make ourselves vulnerable or find out what happens next.
But relief doesn’t always mean we’ve made a good choice, and with time, we can start to see what it’s cost us: The opportunities missed, the words left unsaid, or the version of our life we never explored.
Fear draws our attention to the possible costs of acting. Which doesn’t allow us to consider the possible cost of doing nothing:
What if I’m still wondering about this years from now?
What if the conversation never happens?
What if I was more capable than I allowed myself to discover?
I didn’t know how any of my choices were going to turn out. I only know how differently I feel now about the times I acted and the times I didn’t.
So, when fear appears, perhaps the question isn’t: What am I afraid might happen if I do this?
But also: How might I feel one day if I don’t?
Exercise Focus
In exercise, fear often shows up as putting things off.
I’ll start running when I feel fitter.
I’ll try lifting heavier when I feel more confident.
I’ll join the class when I feel less self-conscious.
Biding our time can feel rational, even sensible. It saves us from discomfort: from getting something wrong, finding it harder than expected, or discovering that we can’t do what we hoped.
But it also prevents us from discovering that perhaps we can.
Every time we avoid a situation, we experience the relief of not having to face it. What we don’t get is any new evidence. We’re left with the same assumptions about what we can and can’t do, how other people might see us, and where we belong.
Acting doesn’t have to be dangerous, terrifying or dramatic. It might simply mean booking the class, asking someone to show you how a machine works, picking up a slightly heavier weight, or lacing up your shoes and committing to the first ten minutes.
The experience may still feel uncomfortable. But it gives reality the chance to answer questions that fear has, until now, been answering for you.
You may discover that something isn’t right for you. But you may also discover that you’re far more capable than fear allowed you to imagine.
Nutrition Focus
With food, fear often shows up as control.
If I let myself have some, I’ll end up eating the whole thing.
If I go out for dinner, I won’t be able to stick to my plan.
If I don’t track what I eat, I’ll lose control.
Diets, meal plans, calorie counting and food rules can make us feel safe. They give us clear instructions and protect us from having to find out whether the things we fear will actually happen.
But they come with a hidden cost: the longer we rely on them, the fewer opportunities we have to test our assumptions.
If we never keep a particular food in the house, we can continue believing that we wouldn’t be able to stop eating it.
If we always decline the meal out, we never discover that one evening can be enjoyed without starting from scratch the next day.
If we track every mouthful, we never find out what might happen if we make and trust our own decisions.
Avoiding these situations gives us immediate relief. But while we try to make sure that the thing we fear never happens, we’re missing out.
A shared meal.
The pleasure of eating something we enjoy.
The freedom to be spontaneous.
The chance to respond to hunger rather than a list of rules.
Challenging those assumptions doesn’t mean pushing every boundary or changing the way we eat overnight.
It might mean including carbohydrates in a meal, eating when we notice we’re hungry, keeping a previously restricted food in the house, or accepting an invitation to dinner without checking the menu first.
Fear tells us what might go wrong if we challenge the rule. It says far less about what we may lose by continuing to follow it.
Explore More
From the archive: Familiarity vs Possibility: Why We Become More Reluctant to Try New Things explores why unfamiliar experiences can feel so uncomfortable, but how we might miss out on opportunities when we allow that feeling to decide for us.
Book: The Chimp Paradox by Steve Peters explores why our brains perceive certain situations as threatening and how confidence develops through experience.
Recipe: My Apricot & Almond Toasted Muesli provides a simple base for a good breakfast, with plenty of room to make it your own. Experiment with different combinations of nuts, seeds and dried fruits, then add yoghurt, milk and fresh fruit to make it something you really enjoy getting up for in the morning.
Takeaway
Comments